The Mets have an unsurvivable problem in their relief corps

Bobby Parnell


Once a legitimate strength of their team, the Mets suddenly find the latest iteration of their bullpen as a serious weak point. Their problem specifically lies the choices to be used in the sixth and seventh innings.

And on Sunday, that weakness got weaker for the Mets, and raised some serious doubt in the process.

Bobby Parnell entered the game on Sunday in a 1-1 tie, seemingly moments after the game resumed after a brief rain delay.

But as was the case on Friday night against the Pirates, Parnell simply had next to no command of his pitches.

And what started out bad ended up far worse.

Eric O'FlahertyParnell allowed a leadoff walk to Pedro Florimon, which just can’t happen in a 1-1 game against the Pirates late. But he managed to induce a comebacker off the bat of Michael Morse, a groundball destined to end up in a 1-6-3 double play.

Not exactly.

Ruben Tejada was somehow late covering the bag, and Parnell ended up throwing the ball – which was on target – into centerfield, as Daniel Murphy failed to back the play up.

Tejada took ownership of the misplay.

“I’m late to the bag,” Tejada acknowledged.

Manager Terry Collins wisely deflected the blame off of Tejada or any one player, and simply said the defense had to make the play.

“The part that really gets me sometimes, we’ve always got to point a finger at somebody. It’s always somebody’s fault,” the manager said. “Sometimes it’s not just one guy. Maybe it just happens. It’s part of the game. We didn’t make the play. We’re supposed to make the play. But I’m not going to lump it on one guy’s shoulders that he was two steps over too far, or the throw was too fast. Everybody is sitting there on the bench, ‘Well, jeez, he should have crow-hopped. He should have been closer to the bag.’ Make the play. It’s the big leagues.”

Whoever was to blame, that’s when the floodgates opened against Parnell, who could not get out of his own way after that misplay.

First, an RBI single by the red-hot Gregory Polanco. Then, after Starling Marte flew out, Travis d’Arnaud was charged with a passed ball to allow another run to score. After Neil Walker drew a walk, Aramis Ramirez singled in a run.

That was all for Parnell, who was relieved by Eric O’Flaherty. And he did Parnell and the Mets no favors, either, as he allowed an opposite field single to lefty Pedro Alvarez which plated Ramirez.

Four runs in, and Parnell, O’Flaherty and the rest of the Mets had been dusted in this three-game series.

“I am a little concerned about Bobby,” manager Terry Collins explained about his former closer. “One of the things that we’ve seen is this roller coaster that these guys coming out of surgery have. One day last week he was 97 [mph]. This week wasn’t as good.”

Parnell’s mechanics are unquestionably different now than they were before the surgery. It’s not clear if that’s the result of rust, the injury to the elbow, his neck, the latter two, or all three. But his arm is clearly behind the rest of his body and it’s resulting in a complete lack of overall command, whether it’s the fastball or knuckle-curve.

What’s worse, as Collins said, the velocity is wildly inconsistent, and when he’s centering his pitches the way he is, he’s just getting absolutely mauled.

Parnell chose not to speak with the media following the loss on Sunday.

The Mets are at the point where a decision needs to be made with Parnell. The easy decision for now is to keep him out of high leverage situations. But the Mets aren’t exactly playing in a lot of laughers lately thanks to their offense which has browned out over the last ten days.

So finding spots for Parnell may be difficult to achieve, and the Mets really can’t afford to have a dead roster spot, especially in the bullpen.

But then there’s O’Flaherty, who was brought in to get left-handed hitters out, and he just hasn’t done that nearly enough since being acquired. It’s somewhat surprising considering he’s been effective throughout his career as a left-handed specialist.

But he’s dealt with a shoulder problem in 2015 and missed some time as a result. There’s no way to truly know what the root cause of his struggles have been in 2015, but his location is way off and it doesn’t seem like he’s getting the necessary swings on his breaking balls, resulting in hitters counts and O’Flaherty being forced to challenge more often that he’d like.

Whatever the case is with either pitcher, the Mets suddenly have a serious problem at this stage of the game, and if they intend to be successful down the stretch of the season, Sandy Alderson has to address this problem sooner rather than later.


Parnell needs to be optioned I don’t care if he refuses then we need to get verrett and goedell back then we need to call up josh smoker who’s killing it in double a then we may be ok with getting just one reliever


You hit the nail on the head. I was thinking the same exact thought. Let him get himself together in the minors. I would send him to Double A. Not because he is that bad but more because Triple A is a hitters park. This was Parnell can work on his mechanics and confidence.


For me the key was not the botched double play as bad as that was but the opening inning walk to a batter that till that point had just one hit and one walk all year long and has a career OPS of under 600. What makes this worse is that Parnell was ahead of him 0-2 and then threw 4 straight balls.

Again I will repeat an observation I have made before – on far to many occasions it seems that Mets pitchers are ahead 0-2 or 1-2 and can’t put the batter away.

Not sure what to do with Parnell until another pitcher is ready but clearly no reason to bring him back next year.


One factor on the missed double play was that Murph actually stepped toward the bag. That’s when Tejada stutter stepped. I love Murph but he sometimes has these brain freezes during critical moments in the game (Saturday night’s throw to third). I think he a long-term DH in the AL. Hurts me to say that, but his defense fails at critical moments.


%d bloggers like this: